Silhouette shot of businesspeople in an office building
Tips & Training

Going beyond the career profile: Are your assumptions leading your sessions?

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Let’s start with a question.

Which professions first come up for you when you read the following statements?

  1. “I’m experiencing compassion fatigue through my work – I can’t keep listening to all this.”
  2. “You don’t know what it is like to have seen someone look me in the eyes with such desperation.”
  3. “The guilt I feel at work is overwhelming. I feel helpless.”
  4. “I find my job boring – I really want more thrill and challenge.”

What if I told you these were some phrases I have heard before from:

  1. Building manager
  2. Plumber
  3. Grocery store cashier
  4. Paramedic

Maybe you are surprised. Maybe not.

But I can bet you won’t see these written in a career profile. That’s my assumption.

Did certain professions spring to mind right away? If so, you were likely using what psychologist Daniel Kahneman, author of Thinking, Fast and Slow,  calls “System 1” thinking: fast, intuitive and automatic, relying on mental shortcuts. Its counterpart, “System 2,” is slow, deliberate and effortful. For simplicity, I’ll refer to these mental shortcuts as assumptions.

For the simplicity, I’ll refer to these mental shortcuts as assumptions.

We make assumptions about everything: what someone will say or not say, how we might feel about a potential situation, and yes, about what working a particular job is like.

I’ll explore how leading with assumptions can affect your understanding of clients’ challenges and goals, share a case study from my practice and offer five actions to help you lead with curiosity instead.

How do assumptions about careers affect your clients?

Assumptions can be helpful and necessary to our survival. They can also be harmful, leading to stereotypes and misconceptions depending on how we use or don’t use them.

Where do these assumptions about careers come from?

Many places. By reading career profiles on government websites, seeing a job on TV, social media, knowing someone who has had that job, observing the job, even you yourself working the job.

But none of these are your client’s experience.

If you go by what you assume, you may be missing crucial information and context to fully support your client.

Knowing about a career is important as it gives a basic understanding, but even if you yourself have done the same job and same tasks, the experience is subjective. If you assume the client experiences things as you do, or anyone/anything other than the client rather, you lose the opportunity to truly listen to the client’s needs.

The client is the expert of their own experience. Yes, there are blind spots, but only they know what their true experience is. Your role as a career development professional (CDP) may be to help them identify their potential challenges and goals  through a lens of curiosity rather than assumption.

You do this by choosing not to lead with your assumptions, letting go of your assumptions, and leaning into their story. Their truth.

Case study

To best illustrate how assumptions about a career interfere in a conversation I’d like to share a short case study to demonstrate how my assumption impacted the conversation, what I did and the result. Details have been changed to protect the client’s privacy.

Client: A financial advisor at a bank who came into the session seeking support for work-related stress. They weren’t sure why but were coming home feeling tired, exhausted, foggy and a feeling of dread before work.

Initial assumptions: Likely work overload, interference of AI, understaffed, poor management

Actual issue creating stress: The client had several files dealing with clients who were end of life, some who he would build a relationship with and never see again. He was listening to family members argue about finances and a lot of sad and traumatic situations and stories, often finding himself in a “counselling” position. The client did not have training on how to navigate the emotional toll and labour, the compassion fatigue, of listening to some painful stories and navigating grief and loss.

The job, nor did his financial training, state: able to handle and hold space for emotionally challenging, traumatic events, and grief and loss.  The client had assumptions about the career too!

New action because of taking down assumptions and leading with curiosity: We worked together on navigating vicarious grief and compassion fatigue to improve work well-being. This included taking a course on self-compassion and even grief to help the client understand how this impacted him and then look at options including getting support from his manager, asking to be assigned to other cases when possible and working on emotional and professional boundaries.

Afternotes: If I stayed using my assumptions, and allowing my assumptions to lead, without curiosity, we may have had a transactional, surface-level session and never have gotten to the crux of the issue.

5 actions to keep assumptions from leading your sessions

What we are really doing here is activating what Daniel Kahneman would call using “System 2.”

  1. Awareness and self-reflection: Due to the automatic, subconscious nature of assumptions, daily reflection and awareness are crucial. This could include listening to recorded sessions (if allowed), mentoring or supervision, setting aside time for reflective journaling. In this area you are just observing and noticing. The more aware you are of your assumptions, the more easily you can “catch and release” them and “leave them at the door” so they do not negatively interfere with the relationship with your client.
  2. Challenge the assumptions with self-reflective questions: Once you recognize the assumption, you can then ask yourself, where did this come from? Is this true? Do I believe this? What if I was wrong? What else might be true? How is this assumption helping or hindering me?
  3. Decide what you want to do with them: Yes, you have choices. They do not need to run your life, nor do you need to lead with them. You can discard them, believe them, challenge them or observe them.
  4. Diversify your pool of information: Think outside government-based career profiles and job descriptions. This will help to break down stereotypes and broaden the scope and understanding you have of a particular job/profession. Examples might include:
  • Informational interviews – no, not for your client to network and explore careers, but for you as a CDP
  • Learn from your experience with clients. Yes, the more clients you work with, the more exposure you will have to different ways of experiencing a specific job.
  • Learn from your clients: Yes, your client is the best source of information because you will hear how they experience the profession. Your client is the expert in their own experience. You want to be the learner, not the knower.
  1. Stay curious: A curious mindset is essential. Even with all the above four steps, I encourage staying in a place of curiosity. It’s hard to be curious and assume at the same time.

I hope this article inspires you to check and challenge your assumptions so you can continue supporting your clients with curiosity supporting them by walking in their truth.

Rachel So Administrator
Rachel So is the Editor of CERIC’s CareerWise website and CareerWise Weekly newsletter. She brings a strong communications background, with more than seven years of experience in community-centred non-profits and a focus on building connection through clear, accessible storytelling. Rachel holds a BSc with a specialization in environment and health from the University of Toronto.
×
Rachel So Administrator
Rachel So is the Editor of CERIC’s CareerWise website and CareerWise Weekly newsletter. She brings a strong communications background, with more than seven years of experience in community-centred non-profits and a focus on building connection through clear, accessible storytelling. Rachel holds a BSc with a specialization in environment and health from the University of Toronto.
Latest Posts
  • Businesswoman sitting on a meeting at boardroom and discussing analyzes and paperwork with coworkers.
  • Young adult businesswoman in audience interacting with presenter, asking questions and engaging in debate. Mixed age participants include managers, employees and investors at summit.

Leave a Response